Manoj Padhi	Right to Education : Is Supreme Court of India implementing Social justice in stead of doing justice ?
Blog	Posted By: manojpadhi on:4/12/2012 12:04:48 AM

Today's Supreme Court Judgement on Right to Education doesn't make sense to me because of several unreasonable reasons.

This would sent a bad precedent for Private Industry Sector as well, because there are many Activists, who would file PIL to implement 25% reservation in IT and non-IT sector, where "talent based hiring" has been the sole criteria.

Basically, Supreme Court said - if you are a private entrepreneur in School Business - Either offer 25% seats to poor students, who can't afford school fees or quit school business.

This is again not applicable to minority schools - Muslim and Christian only schools.

So, what these schools will do ?

They will not close down the schools - but they will pass the 25% free student fee to the 75% paid students.

i.e. if the donation is 75000/- per student - now they have to pay 1 Lakh.

So, what kind of non-sense judgement is this ?

Why the parents of 75% students , who already pay tax to Government, are burdened with this Social Justice or forced Charity ?

if any school has got a specific student:teacher ratio, they have to hire more teachers.

They have to buy more science and other educational kits.

Who will pay for those ?

Any, why minority institutions are left out ?

This is one of the most outrageous decisions beyond common sense.

Is this punishment for being father of a student or becoming a school owner, who doesn't owe a cent to Government ?

What is your take on this ?