Post an Article Comment or Elaborate Your Poll Opinion
Enter Your Name & Location:
Yes / I endorse/ I agree
No or I disagree
Can't say or No Comments
Silence is never been an option for concerned Citizens
Bimal Kumar Khemani
AN EXPERIENCE OF STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, LUCKNOW by a RTI activist.
Posted By: hindtodaynews on:4/29/2008 10:40:34 AM
I, Bimal Kumar Khemani, Saha Prant Sangathan Mantri of AKHIL BHARATIYA GRAHAK PANCHAYAT Braj Prant, a national organization of consumers have formed a group of about 10 dedicated persons to find out corruption with the help of RTI Act, 2005. We have selected few departments viz. Nagar Nigam, Bharat Sanchar Nigam, Aligarh Development Authority, D.S.Degree College, Aligarh Muslim University, Electricity & Health Department. Besides finding out corruption, we also impart training to various Govt. officials and conduct public awareness campaign. In course of a period of almost 2 years we did not get proper information and so have to file about 30/35 appeals before the STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, LUCKNOW. On request of one of our friends to plead his case before the commission on 24-04-08, I had to visit S I C Lucknow.
The State Information Commission office, Lucknow is located on the 6 th Floor of Indira Bhawan. The Govt. of U.P. has allotted an office space about 375 Sq. Mts. for a staff of 10 commissioners and 77 sub-ordinate staff. It has 5 chambers for Commissioners and rest of the space is for the staff and keeping records.
Sri Mulayam Singh Yadaw, ex. Chief minster of the state appointed a retired H.C.Judge, Mr. M.A.Khan as Chief Information Commissioner and 4 other commissioners. Km. Mayawati the present chief minister of the state appointed another 5 commissioners. These appointments give a political smell. So at present there is a total strength of 10 commissioners. But in this “Palatial building” there are only 5 rooms for the commissioners. So commissioners work in shifts. Five sit from 10.00 to 14.00 hrs. and the other five from 14.00 to 17.00 hrs.
Is it not unfortunate ? Is it not a waste of man power and money ? Does it not give out 50% results of
the working capacity ? Does it not show how seriously the Govt. of U.P. takes the State Information Commission ?
There is no Enquiry desk. An enquiry revealed that there are four clerks to receive DAK, sort it out and send it to the respected commissions . Out of these four persons one opens the letters and enters the details in receipt register and puts the receipt numbers on them. I was also told that normally more than 500 letters are received daily and out of them hardly 400/450 letters are opened and entered into the register. So rest are left to cool there heals.
A meeting with the Chief commissioner revealed his easy style of functioning. He graced us to meet us in his retiring room at about 2.00 p.m.. He was shown a list of 31 pending appeals as filed by our group , with a request to get them registered and listed for hearing since more than last 4/5 months have passed . He was also informed that the proper notices of hearing are not received by the appellants and also the copy of the judgments are also not sent to the parties concerned. I was informed that the commission has evolved a noble method for supplying the copy of the decision. One is to apply for a copy as per civil procedure by affixing a court fee stamp of Rs. 10/- and also required to collect the same from the office of the commission. I do not know why at this point the Honorable Chief Information Commissioner got annoyed .and told me to contact Km. MAYAWATI ,and ask her why she is not allotting more funds to the commission. This was also not the end of the drama The retd. High Court Judge cum Chief Commissioner also uttered something and started challenging the role of Khemani as an RTI activist fighting for transparency in the system.
The experience shows that an appeal filed to-day may get lost in the office of the commission or be listed after several months due to shortage of space and funds. It became obvious even in this short visit that the whole atmosphere is political. Chief commissioner and other commissioners, are pro-administration. And they are hesitant to impose penalty on the defaulters u/s.20. If this is going to be the fate of R T I Act then one will like to keep mum and just watch.
BIMAL KUMAR KHEMANI
Saha-Prant Sangathan Mantri,
AKHIL BHARATIYA GRAHAK PANCHAYAT BRAJ PRANT,
2/40D, Janakpuri, Marrish Road,
bimal.khemani at rediffmail.com
Comments By: ruved
Yes / I endorse/ I agree Post Date:3/20/2011 7:25:32 AM
Comments By: Harish Delhi
Yes / I endorse/ I agree Post Date:7/9/2011 1:58:22 AM
Comments By: arvind singh
Yes / I endorse/ I agree Post Date:2/25/2012 5:37:21 AM
Comments By: ram teerath vs power corporation farrukhabad
Yes / I endorse/ I agree Post Date:8/2/2012 9:56:56 PM
POST COMMENT LINK IS AVAILABLE AT TOP OF THIS PAGE
HT e-Magazine - People's News, Blogs and Articles
SAVE INDIA MISSION, AN APPEAL -By Dr Radhasyam Brahmachari
Why not a ministry of majority affairs ? : 53.6 % Scholarships Go to Girl Students under the Post-Matric Scholarship Scheme of the Ministry of Minority Affairs
Orissa Votes 2009 - Citizens are requested to apprise the performances of the following members
If you collect every one of these items Packers and Movers in Pune
Do you know about Top Packers and Movers Mumbai?
Are you currently apprehensive right now concerning shifting
One more aspect about knowledgeable Packers and Movers Services
Car or vehicle Support agency & Transport Program Packers and Movers in Chennai
Easy shifting by having packers and movers in Gurgaon
Useful information to Selecting the proper Movers Packers
TATA REFRACTORIES(BELPAHAR) FACES CLOSURE By Jibanendra Mahanty
Systemic failures in the Directorate general, Indian Shipping Ministry
CEDAR OR LOTE-TREE IN THE LIGHT OF AL-QURAN- A SCIENTIFIC STUDY-A SCIENTIFIC STUDY -By Dr. M.I.H. Farooqi
What is Wrong with AMWAY Business ? Beware of Cheats
Performance review of Naveen Patnaik by Orissa Today Group
SALMAN KHAN’S ‘EK THA TIGER’ BECOMES THE LONGEST-RUNNING TOP VIDEO ON MOBILES, FINDS VUCLIP
Is Hindu Inter caste marriages - Choice of Next generation ? Intellectual debate
REAL MEANING OF HINDU-KUSH - CONVINCING AND LOGICAL REPLY BY DR. KOENRAAD ELST, THE FAMOUS BELGIAN INDOLOGIST
Institution of Engineers (India) Royal Charter 1935-Transcripted By Professional Engineer Suraj Singh
Be first to comment
Browse All Videos
Tirangaa (1992) :: Raaj Kumar Dialogs: Na talwaar ki dhaar se na goliyon ki bauchaar se. Banda darta hai to sirf parvardigaar se
Daily News at Nine (All India Radio)(English-MP3) :: Daily Broadcast at 9 PM IST
KHOJUCHI MUN SURILA MANA (Oriya Album) :: KHOJUCHI MU EKA SURILA MANA
Spotlight (All India Radio) English-MP3 :: Daily Broadcast
Samachar Sandhaya (All India Radio) (Hindi-MP3) :: Daily Broadcast at 9 PM IST
Mo Nidara Thikana (Oriya Album) :: Mo Nidara Thikana Tora Panata
GAPA HELE BI SATA (1977) :: E BANARA CHHAI (Oriya Movie Song)
OSA ELECTION FACE-OFF DEBATES :: OSA Debate 2013 - Know the candidates
Saathi (1991) :: Aaj Hum Tum O Sanam
Dr. Subramanian Swamy :: Dr. Subramanian Swamy on Ms. Sonia Gandhi
M. Kumaran son of Mahalakshmi (2004) :: Tamil Movie Part-1
Kranti (1981) :: Ab Ke Baras Tujhe Dharti Ke Rani Kardenge
Sunday (2008) :: Hindi Movie
Judaai (1997) :: Kadar Khan & Paresh Rawal Comedy
Judaai (1997) :: Kader Khan & Johnny Lever Comedy
India News Talk Radio and TV :: 'Grateful I can serve India' -- NaMo
India News Talk Radio and TV :: 'Grateful I can serve India' -- NaMo
Market Mantra (All India Radio) English-Hindi-MP3 :: Daily Broadcast
Kandhei (Oriya Album) :: HAI MU CHAGALI PUATEA
Daily Talk Show w/ Manoj Padhi (Hindi) :: मोदी से बड़ा कौन है
Some Articles By Same Writer
USCIS - Immigration Benefit Fees for H1B and other type of applications
DHS Extends Eligibility for Employment Authorization to Certain H-4 Dependent Spouses of H-1B Nonimmigrants Seeking Employment-Based Lawful Permanent Residence
U.S. Muslims Feel Backlash from Paris Attack
मैं चुपके से कहता अपना प्यार: जॉन बर्जर
World has no choice but to ban Islam
Should employers obliged to accomodate hijab wearing Muslim women ?
Video Catches Firebomb Thrown at Islamic Center of New Mexico
Candidates Speak at Muslim Voter Forum Co-Hosted by CAIR-San Diego
Return of Barbarianism -By Vidya Bhushan Rawat
CAG report exposes the land scam, Cronyism and Corruption of Odisha CM Naveen Patnaik
Tunisian Youth and Political Life - CSID TUNISIA
Condemn the anti-Madarsa attitude of Telangana government
Khilafah Conferences 2014 in UK
Indian Muslim are much safer than the so called Muslim country -Dr Tasleem Ahmed Rehmani
U.S. Muslims Pass Activism Torch to Youth | CA Water District Accused of Discrimination | CA School Retires 'Arab' Mascot
China and the New Democracy of Mao -By Tony Henderson
CAIR Seeks Probe of Bias Motive for Attack on Muslim Woman in Indiana
Does love know Religious boundaries? -By Ram Puniyani
Mushawarat asks world community to stop the Israeli aggression against Gaza
Condemn the State Minority Commissions report on Kishanbagh police firing
Some Related Articles
Draft Minutes of the Meeting of the Central Information Commission held on 13.9.2011 -By Milap Choraria
Brief Report of RTO Convention in Orissa::Minister admits to the need for reviewing the Rules and administration of RTI Act in the State of Orissa
Brief Report of RTO Convention in Orissa::RTI in orissa, Lost Four Years-Whys and Hows
Suggestion on Implementation of Right to Information Act, 2005 - By Milap Choraria
Coal India Limited asking for exhorbitant amount to part with the RTI info
Information Commission can impose Penalty : Punjab and Haryana High Court
Complaint case against PIO of Orissa Information Commission
MP's, MLA's and Members pof Local Self Governments are within the ambit of Public Authority
Application to Sri Somnath Chatterjee under RTI for a copy of the CNN IBN clippings -By BIMAL KUMAR KHEMANI
INDIA ABROAD News Paper serving the vested interest?
Whether preparation of such a Manipulated Reports, by IT Department, is a general practice? -By Milap Choraria
RTI-BPL Issue :whether the BPL people will be provided information free of cost. AS per section 7(5) of the RTI Act ?
Why Lalu's Railway Ministry is sympathy with the Kolkata Land Mafia?
Online Petitions in English and Kannada against Amendment to Karnataka Right to Information or RTI Act 2005
AN EXPERIENCE OF STATE INFORMATION COMMISSION, LUCKNOW by a RTI activist.
Is KK Mishra fit to stay as KIC of KARNATAKA STATE ?????? with all the baggage he has ??? and for what he has done to RTI Act 2005 ??
APPROACH PAPER FOR P.I.L. ON NON-IMPLEMENTATION OF RTI ACT
USE OF RTI BY POLITICAL PARTIES IN THE NEXT GENERAL ELECTIONS
RTI FARCE IN ORISSA - A LIVE CASE :: Please support Rabin Kumar B.Adhikari
Report of Fact Finding Team on Assault on RTI Activist Sri Ansari of Konark by BDO, Gop Block of Puri District, Orissa - By Shri Pradip Pradhan
HindToday Context Classifieds
WhereIsMyDeal.com: GLOSSYBOX - US Deals - A perfect gift for your girlfriend !!
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Swiss Wrist Deals - Get $100 OFF ANY Rolex Sports Model Watch
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save 15% off any purchase sitewide only at Loehmanns.com Use Code 15OFFJULY712 Ends 7/31 No minimum purchase requirement!
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Hot New Designer Dresses for under $30! Find dresses from top named designers including new arrivals at Loehmann's for 30-65% off! No Code is Needed, Ends 7/15
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save 50% off selected Clearance items! This offer features discounts from the fashion industries top designers only at Loehmann's! Save half on over 60 items, no code is needed, ends 7/17
WhereIsMyDeal.com: This Weekend Only, Save $25 off any $75 purchase at Loehmann's including new arrivals with code SAVE25JULY Ends at midnight 7.15
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Logitech Deals - Save on Dented Box and Refurbished items at Logitech.com
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Logitech Deals - Save 67% on Logitech Webcam C210 (Red or Blue) - Dented Box with coupon code logi_c210_71312 thru Jul 16
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Logitech Deals - Save 50% on Logitech Harmony One Advanced Universal Remote - Refurbished with coupon code logi_h1_71312
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Logitech Deals - Save 63% on Logitech Wireless Mouse M310 (Dark Aces) - Dented Box with coupon code logi_m310_71312
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save BIG at Kensington Hot Offers
WhereIsMyDeal.com: up to 23 % off on top Logitech products and Daily special offers
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Nero Deals - Nero Kwik Media, Nero BackItUp 11,Nero Burning ROM 11 and Nero 11 and Nero 11 Platinum deals
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Roku Deals - Lowest Price Ever On Roku at $49
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Free Child Safety ID kit and Free Insurance Quote from Gerber Life Insurance
WhereIsMyDeal.com: PBS KID SHOP Special offers - 15% off and Free Ground Shipping On Orders of $65+
WhereIsMyDeal.com: techForLess Special offers on computers and electronics. Save 10-50% today
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Hot Deals in Roxio: Digital Media Software for both PC & Mac: Save up to $80
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save Up to 70% on School Supplies at DiscountSchoolSupply.com
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save Big on Daily Hot Deals from NewEgg.com - Updated Daily
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save $150 on AutoCAD LT 2013, AutoCAD Inventor LT Suite 2013 and Autodesk Inventor LT 2013
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Save up to 40% on Acronis Data Backup Recovery Software with Coupons
Stop Snoring Now with MySnoringSolution! Buy 1 - Get 1 Free
Save big on our New York Pass and Double-Decker Bus Tour combo!
FREE Health Insurance Price Comparisons for Individuals and Families
WhereIsMyDeal.com: Sears Outlet Mall up to 70% off
Education Franchise Opportunities for STEM Learning using Raspberry Pi on Linux
Vipul Group - Integrated Townships, Villas, Apartments and Group Housing Projects in India
Apartments or Flats in Bhubaneswar - ZESTATES
YES, I am interested to Volunteer as a watchdog for my country, state, neighborhood for HIND TODAY
YES, I am interested to Advertise on HIND TODAY Print and Digital Edition, whenever the first issue gets out. Please send me your quote.
YES, I am interested to subscribe a HIND TODAY Print or Digital Edition, whenever the first issue gets out
So what Exit Poll is banned by EC :: WhoIsYourChoice.com offers Pre and Post Election Results::Advani is Leading as PM
Must read:: HINDTODAY.COM warning to its readers about new 'work at home scams' including those posted at HINDTODAY.COM
PROPUS INFOTECH and HINDTODAY.COM provides you this once in a life time visionary opportunity::IT enabled Managed Service Kiosks :: Approximate Investment Rs. 10000/- + Computer + Internet + Phone
If you have 5 minutes to spare and 18 years or above - Register at India's e-Election Commission of India : Visit www.WhoIsYourChoice.com
House for Sale
Attn. News Website Owners of India - India's National News Carrier HindTimes.com is coming soon. Please express interest ASAP.
Indian Railways : Passenger Status/PNR Status, Internet reservation and Train Enquiry
CBSE & BSE,Orissa , High School Certificate Exam Result - 2007
Eye Specialists at Berhampur (Orissa)
KALYAN Health Care
Click for Advertisement (Berhampurcity)
Computer Sales & Services
LAND SELLING & BUYING AT CHENNAI
CONSTRUCTION & BUILDERS AT CHENNAI
INDEPENDENT HOUSE DESIGN & CONSTRUCTION
BPO - Accounts and Healthcare Related Analysis (Humana-Wellcare Funding)
SELLING FLAT AT CHENNAI
Bring your Business/Office to web for free
VISITING CARDS / DTP / DESIGNING/INTERNET/WEBADVT.
LOWEST AIR & SEA FREIGHT FROM DELHI TO WORLDWIDE
LEARN LIVE PROJECTS ON ADVANCED SOFTWARE LANGUAGES AND GET THE CERTIFICATION FROM USA
Advanced Software Language and Project Training with Placement assistance from India's No.1 Project Training Institute
Plots Available at outskirts of Bhubaneswar
Looking to work on Real IT projects ? Visit www.projectschool.com today
Propus Infotech (P) Ltd.
Terms of Service